Skip to main content

Why Bus Operators Should Absolutely Rush to Avoid the 85th Percentile Scheduling Method

Is your bus service truly as efficient as it claims to be, or is it falling victim to overcomplication? Discover how the 85th percentile scheduling method, hailed as a solution, might be more of a curse than a blessing, turning everyday operations into a chaotic, costly mess. Does the promise of precision justify the headaches that come with it? Find out why simplicity might just be the better path to long-term success.


Why the 85th Percentile Scheduling Method Could Be More Trouble Than It’s Worth

Oh, the marvel that is the 85th percentile bus scheduling method! A system so intricate, so demanding, and so utterly impractical, it’s practically begging to be ignored by anyone with an ounce of common sense. While its proponents wax lyrical about “precision” and “efficiency,” let’s take a closer look at why this supposedly revolutionary idea is more trouble than it’s worth.

First, let’s talk about the data requirements. Because, of course, every bus operator has a treasure trove of perfectly pristine, hyper-detailed data just lying around, waiting to be crunched. Never mind that collecting it involves extensive surveillance of travel times, traffic patterns, and passenger demand down to the minute. Small operators in particular must surely enjoy this Herculean task, probably jotting down traffic flow statistics on the back of a napkin while juggling actual day-to-day operations. What’s a little extra data collection between friends?

Complexity Breeds Chaos

Then, there’s the joy of computational complexity. If you’ve ever wished that scheduling buses could feel more like piloting a spaceship, then this is the method for you. The algorithms are so advanced, they make quantum mechanics look like child’s play. All you need is a state-of-the-art system, a team of data scientists on speed dial, and a bit of wizardry. Oh, and if you’re running a modest bus company without access to a supercomputer? Well, tough luck. Perhaps you can calculate it all manually with an abacus.

But the real fun begins once you actually implement the schedules. Say goodbye to predictability and hello to chaos! The 85th percentile method spits out these beautifully flexible timetables that are about as reliable as British weather forecasts. Planning staff rosters? Coordinating vehicle maintenance? Good luck with that. Drivers will love the erratic shift patterns, passengers will revel in the excitement of never knowing when their bus might arrive, and managers will have a delightful time explaining why half the fleet is in the wrong place at the wrong time.

And let’s not forget the passengers, who will definitely appreciate the new system. Who needs fixed schedules anyway? Everyone knows that people just love turning up to a bus stop and playing a fun game of “guess when the bus is coming.” It’s practically a community-building exercise! And for those lucky enough to catch the bus, they can spend their journey pondering the statistical elegance of the 85th percentile, rather than worrying about whether they’ll make it to work on time.

Now, let’s talk about costs. Surely, operators have an endless budget to throw at software licenses, advanced analytics tools, and specialist staff training. Money grows on trees, doesn’t it? Small operators, in particular, will leap at the chance to pour resources into this shiny new system instead of, say, keeping their ageing buses on the road. After all, who needs a functioning vehicle fleet when you’ve got a cutting-edge scheduling method?

But wait, there’s more. Imagine trying to use this method in rural areas, where traffic conditions are so consistent you could set your watch by them. Why on earth would you want a straightforward, predictable schedule when you can overcomplicate things? Or better yet, try it on a brand-new route, where there’s no historical data whatsoever. Surely guessing the 85th percentile travel time is as good as actual data, right?

So, let’s give credit where it’s due: the 85th percentile scheduling method is a brilliant way to waste time, money, and goodwill. It’s perfect for those who love over-engineering solutions to problems that don’t exist, alienating passengers, and introducing operational headaches. For everyone else, sticking with tried-and-tested scheduling methods will do just fine, thank you very much.

In summary, if you’re a bus operator who enjoys unnecessary stress, endless expense, and confused passengers, then by all means, dive headfirst into the 85th percentile method. For the rest of the industry, feel free to give it the wide berth it so richly deserves.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Rolling Chronicles: Life, Lanes, and Lessons from the Driver’s Seat

As a city bus driver, I'm not just steering through traffic, I'm navigating a sea of stories, personalities, and unexpected moments. From heartfelt conversations to the chaos of the commute, every ride is an unscripted adventure. So, join me behind the wheel as we dive into the life and lanes of public transport, where every journey has a tale to tell. Navigating the City Through Stories: The Bus Driver’s Perspective on Life and Lanes Public transit isn’t just about getting from point A to B, it’s a living, breathing network of people, stories, and unexpected moments. This blog is where bus drivers, transport pros, and curious passengers come together, sharing experiences from behind the wheel and beyond. As a city bus driver, I’m more than just a navigator, I’m a storyteller, a streetwise sage, and sometimes even an impromptu therapist. Every shift is an unscripted adventure, filled with colourful characters, urban rhythms, and the occasional bit of chaos. From late-night conf...

Route Learning Log: Service 21 – Clovenstone to Royal Infirmary

I’ve never driven the 21, but I already know its rhythm: the sharp inhale before a narrow turn, the lull of wide suburban streets, the murmur of students crossing in Sighthill, and the quiet expectation of reaching the Royal Infirmary.  Today, it exists only in my notebook, in imagined brake lights and familiar smells of the city, as I try to memorise six sections of Edinburgh one careful corner at a time. Clovenstone to Sighthill – The Estate Escape Clovenstone’s your starting pistol, low-rise flats, stairwells, and the sound of doors shutting just as you pull up. Wester Hailes Park and Hailesland Place blend into each other with that west Edinburgh rhythm: plenty of crossing points, kids darting across the grass shortcuts, and the odd shopping trolley that’s somehow migrated half a mile from the supermarket. Murrayburn Park brings more of the same before Westside Plaza appears, part shopping centre, part social hub, part clock you can set your watch by. From there, Calder Drive s...

Homework Run: Scouting Service 4 from Queen Margaret University to Snowsports Centre

From coastline breezes to hilltop views, I’m plotting the perfect route, before I’ve even touched the steering wheel. Crossing Edinburgh without leaving my chair: A homework journey on Service 4. A desk-chair journey across Edinburgh, from campus calm to Pentland peaks, undertaken with nothing but a stop list, an overactive imagination, and the faint hope that the live version won’t involve too much swearing. Section 1: The Academic Warm-Up We start at Queen Margaret University, a place where the roads are wide, the air is fresh, and the biggest hazard is probably a student wandering out mid-scroll on their phone. From Queen Margaret Drive to Milton Link, it’s all fairly civilised, the sort of stretch where you think, I could do this all day. Then comes Corbiewynd and Parrotshot. According to Street View, these are perfectly normal residential turns. But I’ve driven enough “normal” turns to know they can become “hold-my-coffee” moments once real-life Edinburgh drivers get involved. By ...